Rerurn to Romy the Cat's Site


In the Forum: Audio For Dummies ™
In the Thread: Goto SG-370DX measurement
Post Subject: OK??Posted by Romy the Cat on: 3/17/2018
 Daniel wrote:
This is a bit of a childish "I'm right! - No, I'm right! - No, I'm right!" 'discussion'. I know that there are differences between acouctic live, amplified live and playback of a recording and never stated there wasn't or one could ever be mistaken for the other.
But I don't think we need to argue that certain systems fail to transport certain aspects of musical presentation. And some others fail a little less.
Daniel, I do not think that this is childish 'discussion' and I assure you that I am very far from a desire to convince you in anything. Generally, at this site people do not try to convince others and deeply individualistic approach is more suitable in here. I reacted to what I felt was appropriate and if you feel that it was not appropriate then it is fine. For one person “something” might be a deep philosophical postulation and for another person the very same “something” might be just a blabbering in open air.  The fact that certain systems fail or success to transport certain aspects of musical presentation has very little relation to what I was saying. I do feel that you did not “get” what I was advocated and it is fine…    
 martinshorn wrote:
Daniel, seeing your words describing needs for live sound, i seriously recommend to copy Klaus Speth' System in a first instance.
Here we go. Let me to bring a counterpoint to this. The best experience from Rachmaninoff Second Concerto, including multiple very fine live performance, I had approximately 10 years ago when I rented U-Hall truck and played Janies CD at the truck’ s stock system. So, following the Martinshorn’s recommendation if you, Daniel, want to get the best in sound reproduction then rent U-Hall truck. :-)

Rerurn to Romy the Cat's Site