Rerurn to Romy the Cat's Site


In the Forum: Horn-Loaded Speakers
In the Thread: Magico: Robert Harley’s upperbass mouth.
Post Subject: Audio reviews portray a lot.Posted by Romy the Cat on: 2/21/2006

 Gregm wrote:
Amazingly, some people are influenced. They refer to what X golden-ear or Y guru reviewer has to say as important, ground-breaking news... Uncanny!
Weeeeeeeeeell, not realy. I feel that the reviews influence everyone. The question is what to pay attention when a review is published.

It is not secret that any review before accepted for publishing is viewed and signed off by a manufacturer. It is not that the manufacturer necessary writhe the reviews (although I know some event when this did actual happen) but rather a manufacturers reviews that the basic presented facts are correct and that the basic messages are passed correctly.

Let to leave along the Robert Harley’s comment how the system sounded. Look at the part of the Robert writing what was clearly inspired by the Magico marketing presentation itself. 

What Robert Harley said describing the Magico speaker is EXECLY what is in a head of the Magico designer. The realty is that was nothing in that review that indicated any reasoning for Magico impetrations, any sound related motivations or any demonstration of design intelligence or intention. The review indicates that the only motivation to make the speakers  was a feeling that the idiots-US-consumers will be thrilled with any speakers that reminds the BMW’s body, that cost $200K and inspired Robert Harley to have a RMO (a Reviewer’s Multiple Orgasm) while he was listening them. It’s it. There is apparently nothing behind the Magico and there was nothing else that a Magico guy is able to say about his speakers. The Harley’s review is very clearly portrays it.

So, do you feel that reviews are not influential? I disagree. They are, if one knows what to pay attention, are a wonderful tool to learn what does not deserved to be heard. Am I mistaken? Perhaps. Visit the Magico guy and talk with him about his speakers. Then you will learn WHY Harley pulled out if his ass words trying to say SOMETHING about the Magico.

Am I mistaken? Well, as usually….

Rgs,
Romy

Rerurn to Romy the Cat's Site