Rerurn to Romy the Cat's Site


In the Forum: Off Air Audio
In the Thread: The best audio source EVER!
Post Subject: It had happened to me many many times.Posted by Romy the Cat on: 7/27/2011
fiogf49gjkf0d

 mats wrote:
A couple of nights ago WFMT re-broadcast a concert I had attended some weeks earlier.  It was the Emerson SQ performing in the lovely Martin Theater at Ravinia.  On the program were the last quartets by Haydn, Bartok and Schubert.  I sat about 20 rows back, and a little off to the side.  The performance was good, but ultimately only moderately satisfying.  Maybe I was too far back, or the dinner too heavy, or the folks around me a bit dull, but I could not get very excited.

Then came the WFMT broadcast, produced by Kerry Frumkin and recorded by Hudson Fair.  What a difference!  Two microphones, in what must have been the absolute sweet spot of the hall, captured the large, detailed and very exciting sound of the Emerson.  It was a great blend of bold scale, integration, dynamics and tone, much different from my live experience.  So often we hear about the disapointment of coming home from a concert to our stereos, but here was an example of how the, surely different, sound of a recording could lead to something very good.  I think Romy has written about the goal in audio not being to recreate the sound of the performance, but to generate a meaningful event.  Well, this evening with WFMT validated the efforts by musicians, recordist, producer, radio station, equipment makers, and system integration.  Most satisfying art!

I think to a great extend it is due to the fact during the FM broadcast the sound is mixed for the microphones that are hanging just above conductor.  When you are in the hall then you can get any mix and it will be greatly depends from where you sit.  No further than last weekend a local friend of my was complaining that BSO was planning last weekend Beethoven 7 an brass was flooding the whole sound. The FM broadcast quite in contrary presented so phenomenal brass balance and quality that it made me to speak about it publicly:

http://classical-scene.com/2011/06/24/wcrbs-tanglewood-coverage/comment-page-1/#comment-7167

I do feel that in many cases the FM broadcast is more palatable for consumption then live event, at least after FM broadcast you do not need to stay 2.5 hour in traffic jam in the Tanglewood exit of MassPike…

Rgs, Romy the Cat

Rerurn to Romy the Cat's Site