GoodSoundClub - Romy the Cat's Audio Site

In the Forum: Horn-Loaded Speakers
In the Thread: Small double bass horn for 3"-8" driver

Post Subject: The “phantom fundamental” BS idea.Posted by Romy the Cat on: 6/29/2010

Haralanov, do not write stupid posts, you have “no experience and no knowledge” about it. Also, do not propose to look at any other speakers as looking is very a deceptive activity. There is a phenomenon of vision that called “phantom visual reality”. It implies that if object is not there but if it very much wanted to be there then the existence of object considered actual. It like if you crave turkey sandwich, you have no sandwich but your stomach have produced the acid to consume the sandwich then the sandwich is consider eaten. You, Haralanov, with your “limited experience” do not know how to yank your left ear in order your digestion system created the right acid trigger the effect phantom perception. You in your ultimate ignorance are running around a yard, trying to catch a turkey, kill it, cook it and make a sandwich from it. Moreart is much more sophisticated - he does not bother with cooking turkey or knowing how to do it. He knows however that a turkey will eventually get converted into bowel movement and he is trying to mimic the after-turkey bowel movement in order to convince a gourmet eater that a phantom turkey sandwich was delicious….

Moreart, you have a strange and wrong vision of interaction protocol at this site. There is no community in here what you need to convince in anything. People in here are on their own and they care only about themselves and own results. Whatever you do you do for yourself only – you feel yourself a bellybutton of Universe – good for you, trust me, no one cares. You did post the explanation how your speaker works. You have push-pull horns and one horn does something to another. It is elegant but it is irrelevant. The effect you get might be described by LCR resonating chain? It was done zillion times. Regardless what you say your horns are “DIY Pipes” and it is very irrelevant what you do with resonating of damping of drivers. Do you understand that the driver I and ANY behavior of the driver in the topology of your horns is irrelevant?

BTW, if you would like to talk then can you tell me how your speaker sounds in compare if it were not using the “phantom fundamental” BS idea. Oh, BTW, why from your experienced point of view the musical instruments are not being made utilizing the “phantom fundamentals” concept? Would it be great to have a flute that produce impact of tuba and to have a fiddle that would make Giovanni Bottesini to feel that lived his live meaninglessly.

Romy the caT

Rerurn to Romy the Cat's Site