Rerurn to Romy the Cat's Site
In the Forum: Horn-Loaded Speakers
In the Thread: Small double bass horn for 3"-8" driver
Post Subject: Why I don't like back loaded hornsPosted by Markus on: 6/29/2010
fiogf49gjkf0d
I am on record as not liking back loaded
horns:
- to be effective at bass frequencies, a BLH needs to be as long
as a FLH would be; I've yet to see a BLH, with the possible exception
of the Tannoy Westminster, that actually has a long enough horn path for
supporting bass frequencies down into the real low bass.
- the horn mouth needs to be the correct size for bass frequencies;
few, if any, are.
- sound needs a finite time along the BLH. It then mixes with the
direct sound from the driver. The sound from the BLH will always be out
of phase with the directly-radiated sound. At certain frequencies, it
will be 360° out of phase, or multiples thereof, and will reinforce the
directly-radiated sound. At other frequencies, it will be 180° out
of phase, or 540° etc, and lead to a cancellation. At most frequencies,
it will be somewhere in between. At all frequencies, it will lead to
time smear. It's debatable how much that matters at low frequencies, but
it'd be better to avoid this time smear.
- most BLHs fire the bass towards the back wall, and almost all at a
different height from the direct radiator, which results in a very
different way of loading the room.
- all existing BLHs are folded. There's a very good argument to be
made that the different sections of the BLH actually act as resonators
at specific frequencies; if you look a the frequency response of
real-word BLHs, they all show a series of peaks and valleys.
- another way of looking at BLHs is to see them as transmission lines;
they would probably be more effective if built to the rules of
transmisson lines.
- transmission lines are really only needlessly complicated bass
reflex alignments. Instead of a BLH, you'd probably get better results
from a properly sorted BR alignment.
I've yet to hear a BLH with bass as good as that from a really
well-sorted BR cabinet. Just my 2 euro cents, mind, and I'm sure others
will disagree.
Rerurn to Romy the Cat's Site